Magdalena Hendey (2 of 4)

Butternut squash and Goats cheese pasties

I live in Devon, I am so lucky to be here. We have several beaches on our doorstep, the wilderness of Dartmoor only a few minutes away.  If we are ever bored (not that we are!)  we can jump in a car to explore the beautiful county of Cornwall which is only a short drive away.

The South West region is famous for pasties. Traditionally filled with beef, potatoes and onion, nowadays they come in so many different varieties, I have even sampled a thai chicken pasty.  Since I am not a great traditionalist and I love messing and experimenting in the kitchen, my pasties are filled with roasted butternut squash and goats cheese encased  in cheesy pastry and sprinkled with black onion seeds for extra flavour. Delicious!  Perfect with a pint of Tribute or Doombar… or a cheeky Hobgoblin.

Magdalena Hendey (1 of 4)

Magdalena Hendey (3 of 4)

Magdalena Hendey (4 of 6)

Magdalena Hendey (1 of 1)



Butternut squash and Goats cheese pasties.

Cheese shortcrust pastry

  • 200g plain flour
  • 100g unsalted butter, chilled and diced
  • 100g Cheddar cheese
  • pinch of salt
  • pinch of black pepper
  • 3tbs of ice cold water

I think the best method to make a good shortcrust pastry is in food processor as it doesn’t like being handled too much.  Put the flour, salt, pepper into food processor add diced butter and process for I would say a minute or so, until mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.  Add the cheese and ‘pulse’ it until mixed in, add water and ‘pulse’ it again.  The pastry should come together in a ball.  Take it out, shape it into a ball, wrap it in clingfilm and chill for at least 30 minutes.


  • 1 medium Butternut squash
  • 2 tsp olive oil
  • 200g goats cheese (I buy a goat cheese log, it has delicious flavour but not too strong, it is really up to you how cheesy you want them to be, remember with goats cheese a little goes a long way)
  • 1tsp sesame seeds
  • pinch of salt and good grinding of black pepper
  • few basil leaves torn or dried basil
  • 1egg for glazing
  • 1tbs of black onion seeds (Nigella seeds)

You must roast the Butternut squash firstly.  Heat you oven to 200C.  Peel the Butternut squash and dice it in a size of a game cube.  Put it into a roasting tin add the oil, salt, pepper and toss it gently.  Place in the preheated oven and roast for about 30/40 min until tender and turning slightly brown on the edges. Sprinkle the sesame seed, basil and put aside to cool down. Slice or crumble the Goats cheese.

Meanwhile, lightly sprinkle your worktop with flour, then roll out the dough, not too thick only a few millimetres, it must be thick enough to hold the stuffing. I used a lid of the pan 16 cm in diameter to cut out circles but anything else like a bowl or plate similarly sized will do.  Cut the pastry circles out, they are going to be folded in half. Place the filling on one half of the circle, Butternut squash topped with cheese and sprinkled with basil.  Leave a 1cm border around edges.  beat the egg in a bowl and using a pastry brush, brush the edges of the circle.  Fold the pastry over the filling and press firmly, you can pinch and fold the pastry sideways to give that nice edge, or press it with the back of the fork for a striped pattern.  Arrange the pasties on the lined baking sheet, glaze it with the beaten egg and sprinkle with the black onion seeds (Nigella seeds).  Bake in the preheated oven for about 25/30 minutes until they lovely golden brown.  Enjoy hot or cold.

11 thoughts on “Butternut squash and Goats cheese pasties”

    1. Yes you could freeze them. Before cooking would be better and then cook from frozen or freeze cooked pasties, let them defrost in an ambient temperature and warm up in an oven. 🙂

  1. I am a retired old lady who is blessed with time to bake, cook, read and sew. It’s taken me awhile to adapt to “spare time” but I seem to finally be getting used to it. I’m drawn to your site because of how beautifully it’s designed. I was looking for a pastie recipe using butternut squash and found Mush & Co. I feel like Ponce de Leon might have felt if he’d discovered “the fountain of youth”. I know this recipe will be splendid. Can’t wait to make it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *